The Gay Science: Learning Eucharistic Theology from Louis Weil

The Rev. Dr. Louis Weil died this past week at the age of 86. Tributes have been pouring into social media platforms from around the country and around the world for a man who was a “pillar of the church,” a “giant in liturgical scholarship,” and an “architect of the 1979 Book of Common Prayer.”

Louis was one of my teachers and mentors, a dear friend, and also a gay man.

Louis’ sexual orientation matters for several reasons, not least in this era when LGBT civil rights are once again being contested (most notably in Texas and Florida), but also because the Church will still (in many locations) happily receive the tireless offerings of time, talent, and treasure from her LGBT members as long as we don’t mention the “gay part.”

Lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and otherwise uncategorized queer people have always populated the Christian Church from the very beginning, but only the scarcest few have been known and named that way prior to the modern period. Naming ourselves, coming out, and being known carries a cost, even today. And for those who grew up when Louis did, the price could have been his vocation and career.

Rather than once again erasing a hard-won identity marker or pretending that being gay didn’t matter or play any role in what someone like Louis Weil offered to the church (which is an incalculable gift), I want to urge all of us who identify in some fashion as “LGBT” and who knew Louis, even only casually or briefly, to start sharing gay stories about him—the painful and the joyous. This matters not only for the integrity of his legacy but also for all the queer kids, clergy, and teachers out there who need to know (and for some of them, as a matter of life and death) that the Communion of Saints is now a bit gayer than it was. I’ll start:

I came out as a gay man while I was a student at Wheaton College (the private Christian one near Chicago) and struggled mightily with how to remain a Christian. I thought becoming an Episcopalian would help (and it did) but not sufficiently to exorcise all my homophobia demons. As Louis confirmed for me years later, homophobia often sends down the toughest roots in gay people themselves; forty years later, there are still more left to yank out of my heart and soul.

I managed to get into the ordination process and start seminary by making a foolish vow—not the first time God has heard one of those. I promised the rector of my sponsoring parish at the time—this was in 1984—that I would remain celibate as a condition for securing his approval to seek ordination.

This whole arrangement felt fraught and tenuous, as foolish vows usually do. I was entirely unsure of how to live or what to think as I told this story to Louis. I sat in one of his enormous wingback chairs in his living room, in a house I would come to know well during my time at Nashotah House Seminary in Wisconsin. Louis was my academic advisor, and our decades-long friendship began right there, in my first week of seminary, as tears trickled down my cheeks.

“I feel called to priesthood,” I mumbled, “but I’m gay. I don’t know how to do this.”

“I don’t either,” Louis said, kindly. “Nobody does. That’s why we need God’s grace—and each other.”

Perhaps only other LGBT people will understand why that simple sentence changed my life. It was one of the very first times I felt completely safe as an out gay man in a church-related context, and the tears turned quickly from a trickle to a flood, washing me with gratitude—or as Louis would say, “drenching me in grace.”

The Chapel at Nashotah House Episcopal Seminary

I cannot begin to list or calculate all that I learned from Louis Weil liturgically and theologically, nor all the rich reasons he illustrated for why Eucharist stands at the very center of Christian faith and practice. To be clear, I don’t mean that Louis taught a “gay Eucharist,” but it does matter that he knew, from the inside out, what a whole-hearted, full-throated, and loving welcome means and why it is mission-critical to whatever the Church wants Eucharist to do and perform.

And that word matters, too—perform. Louis was himself an accomplished musician (at the piano and organ) and was a lover and patron of the performing arts. Without question, that love shaped his convictions about Eucharistic liturgy in ways that in turn shaped generations of clergy in making the Eucharistic Table a place of invitational beauty. Now that I have returned to full-time parish ministry after years of teaching in a seminary (just as Louis had), everything I do at the Table—and which has garnered so much grateful attention in this parish—is thanks entirely to Louis.

One thing more has garnered attention here about my work as the rector of this parish—being gay. Being fully out in the search process for a parish in an LGBT resort town, I honestly didn’t think being gay would matter much here. It does. (And I can see the impish grin on Louis’ face as I write this.)

I’ve been surprised by the resistance from some in this parish to including explicit mention of LGBT people in our congregation’s welcome statement, and by the discomfort (among some) when I fly a rainbow flag on the rectory, and also by the tearful hugs at the local LGBT Pride festival when queer people see our church’s booth—in 2022, even now, making religious support for LGBT people fully visible and explicit still matters; for some it’s life-changing, and for others it’s life-saving.

I am grateful beyond words for all that I learned from Louis Weil, and for all that he offered to the Church that he loved so dearly, which did not always know how to love him back. Now, as I stand at the Eucharistic Table in this parish, week by week, I am reminded of his great exhortation to parish clergy: “keep the main thing the main thing.” And that “main thing” is our Eucharistic worship, which carries a grace powerful enough to welcome all to the feast of God’s love, no exceptions. For the centrality of that foundational insight in our Prayer Book worship, the Episcopal Church can thank Louis Weil.

Louis was also a gay man, openly and proudly.

And that (still) matters.

Author: The Rev. Dr. Jay

I'm an Episcopal priest, parish pastor, and Christian theologian as well as a writer, teacher, and occasionally, a poet. I'm committed to the transforming energy of the Christian gospel and its potential to change the world -- even today. Now that's peculiar, thank God!

20 thoughts on “The Gay Science: Learning Eucharistic Theology from Louis Weil”

  1. A beautiful, stunning tribute to Louis – and, if I may say, to the spirit and courage in you that got you through those rough patches so that you could be a loving example to us future LGBT priests who were your grateful students, dear Jay. Thank you.

    1. Thank you for this wonderful tribute and heart-felt call for LGBT stories. Louis Weil was required reading at Sewanee (T’02) along with Hatchett and others. His Eucharistic centrality is essential medicine for a world often torn by rancor. The table is big enough, expansive enough, for all.

      1. Thank you so much for taking the time to respond here, Jonathan. I’m grateful for your words about Louis! Many blessings to you as we travel through Lent toward Holy Week and Easter!

  2. I love this so much – I’ve been telling people a LOT lately that “All Are Welcome” is the Church’s version of “All Lives Matter.” Because what I really see in “All Are Welcome” is “All are welcome to tithe, but not to be fully sexed or gendered or raced.”

    Love you to bits, my friend.


    Dr Peter P. C. Carlson

    144 Tranquila Circle

    Camarillo, CA 93012


    From: Peculiar Faith Reply-To: Peculiar Faith Date: Saturday, March 12, 2022 at 10:11 AM To: “” Subject: [New post] The Gay Science: Learning Eucharistic Theology from Louis Weil

    The Rev. Dr. Jay posted: ” The Rev. Dr. Louis Weil died this past week at the age of 86. Tributes have been pouring into social media platforms from around the country and around the world for a man who was a “pillar of the church,” a “giant in liturgical scholarship,” and an “arc”

  3. Thank you so much, Jay, for this very beautiful remembrance of someone I never met, but very much admire. I’m so happy that you experienced his beautiful welcome to seminary and that your friendship with him has formed you into the wonder-filled person you are.

  4. Beautiful, Jay. I love this: ‘Making religious support for LGBT people fully visible and explicit still matters; for some it’s life-changing, and for others it’s life-saving.’ You and Louis both have saved lives.

  5. Jay .. what full-throated, gratitude formed tribute to your mentor and friend, Father Louis. I hope this finds you flourishing my friend.. John (

  6. Thanks, Jay. It is heartwarming to read the tributes to Louis, each one contributing another piece to the puzzle. Yours was beautiful.

    1. Hi, Linda! I’m so embarrassed that I lost track of comments for quite some time. My blog was a bit broken and I had to do a major revamp and upgrade. I lost things along the way, including your lovely note. Thank you!

  7. I’m late to the party, but just as grateful for your words and insistence on honoring ALL of who Louis was. I struggle most every day with how to help folks understand that being lesbian isn’t just a “trait” like blue eyes or being left-handed; it is as much a source of my being-ness as living into my priesthood is. Neither of them is something I *do*; they are both a part of who I AM. And who I AM drives how I represent/honor/manifest God and (to a lesser degree) the Church. Because of Louis, I don’t worry about the minutiae of liturgy as much as I worry about the welcome it extends to everyone who comes to the table.

  8. This was such a beautiful tribute to Louis! Thank you Jay! And your godson shares that beautiful name!

    1. Hi, Dear Laura! I lost track of a bunch of blog-related things for quite a while. My blog was in need of revamping and upgrading. I lost things in the process, including you lovely comment! BIG Easter Hugs to you!

  9. Dear Jay – Across the miles and years somehow on Holy Saturday to have come across your beautiful, whole-hearted and full-throated tribute to your mentor and friend Louis Weil on Holy Saturday in another gay resort town (Provincetown) where my partner and I have just moved to a unit in a retirement community to be able finally to be here for much of the summer was a gift and grace….It was like hearing the Exultet.. With gratitude and affection, john (mcdargh) .

Leave a Reply